5th May 2010

Waterproof eyeshadows: YSL and Estee Lauder

By Get Lippie

I had no idea YSL actually did a waterproof shadow until I found this little beauty recently! YSL Fard Lumiere Aquaresistant in #2 Amethyst Grey, which is actually a cool-taupe shade with just a hint of silver shimmer:

This feels very different on the skin to my normal crease and budge-proof shadows (Benefit Creaseless Creams, for reference) they’re very cool, and more of a mousse texture than other ones I’ve tried.  That said, this stuff does not budge once it’s in place.  It’s still pretty easy to blend though.  But the brush that comes with it:

should just be thrown away.  For a £20 product, the brush is utterly useless.  I’ve been using my (clean) fingers to apply, and find this helps spread the product much better.

Onto one that’s much more familiar, Estee Lauder’s Double Wear Eyeshadow cream:

This is the shade Pink Amethyst (spotted the link between the two shades yet?), this feels more greasy in texture, and takes a few seconds to set once you’ve applied it, but once it’s one, it’s going nowhere, here’s how it looks on the skin:

Now, I love my Benefit Creaseless creams to an almost absurd degree, but this one comes in a poor third in a comparison of those, and the YSL.  It’s a nice shade, and it doesn’t crease or run, but it doesn’t blend as well as the other two formulations, and I find it feels a little “rubbery” once it has set.  Also, I find that you can’t apply other (powder) shadows over the top as well. They tend to ball up, and drop off, has this happened to anyone else?  Is there something I’m doing wrong?

Here’s a comparison of how the two formulations look on the skin:

What’s probably not apparent from this swatch is that the YSL has a matte finish – albeit with silver shimmer – but the Estee Lauder has a more visible cream-sheen to it.  They’re both nice shades, but I think I’ll get more wear out of the YSL.  The Lauder is cheaper though, at £15 for the pot, as opposed to the YSL’s £20 (which made even me blanch slightly, as I don’t think it will actually last all that long, being a whipped mousse rather than a cream).

What’s your go-to waterproof shadow?

The Fine Print: I bought these and I have the receipts to prove it.  And the overdraft.